,

How to Choose a QSA Company for a PCI DSS Assessment

Start by confirming that a company appears on the PCI SSC QSA List and is qualified in every region your assessment covers. Then compare its independence, the skills of the people who would lead your work, how it handles remote activity, and how it reviews quality. These checks show whether a company fits your environment.

What a QSA company does

A Qualified Security Assessor (QSA) is an individual employed by a QSA company. PCI SSC qualifies both the company and the employee. Together they validate your cardholder data environment (CDE) scope, evaluate any compensating controls, test the requirements, and state an opinion on whether you meet PCI DSS.

Your organization still has responsibilities. You define scope, supply documentation, remediate issues, and submit the report as directed. Not every entity needs a QSA, because your acquirer or payment brand decides how you validate. If that is still open, start with SAQ vs ROC.

Selection criteria

Listing and current status

Check the QSA List on the PCI SSC website, and use the search tool to confirm the assigned assessors. Only listed companies and employees are recognized to perform PCI DSS assessments. Companies and employees must requalify every year, so check close to when you sign.

Look at how the listing appears. PCI SSC marks a company in red while it is in the Quality Remediation program. A listing confirms qualification only. The QSA Agreement bars a company from claiming PCI SSC endorsement or recommendation without written consent.

Regional coverage

QSA companies may work only in the regions or countries where they are qualified, as shown on the QSA List. The Program Guide gives a clear example: a U.S. merchant with in-scope offices in Singapore needs a company qualified for both the USA and Asia Pacific. Match the list to every in-scope location before you compare proposals.

Independence

Independence affects how far you can rely on the result. Ask each company to explain how it meets these rules:

  • It cannot assess an entity it controls, is controlled by, shares common control with, or has invested in.
  • It must disclose in the ROC when a customer uses security products or services it developed, configured, or manages.
  • When it recommends its own product as remediation, it must also recommend other market options.
  • It cannot state or imply that PCI DSS requires its products or services.
  • It needs separation of duties so that assessors stay free of conflicts of interest.

Consider this rule if you plan to use the customized approach. PCI DSS says a QSA who helps design or implement a customized control cannot derive tests for that control or assess it. Decide early whether you want help designing controls, and from whom.

The people assigned to your work

Each QSA employee needs at least one year of experience in application, information systems, and network security. Each also needs a year in IT security auditing and in risk assessment or risk management, plus one professional certification from each of two PCI SSC lists. These are minimum requirements, so ask about relevant experience beyond them.

Ask who will lead your assessment and whether that person has trained on PCI DSS v4.0.1. QSA employees may assess only against versions they have trained on. The Program Guide also requires appropriate skills, including technology and language, and an understanding of your business. Ask for examples that resemble your payment channels and architecture.

Also ask about staffing. Associate QSA employees may assist with assessments, and subcontracted QSA work requires prior written consent from PCI SSC for each worker.

Onsite and remote work

A QSA does not always have to be onsite. The Program Guide expects assessors to be present onsite or to perform remote activities under applicable PCI SSC guidance. Remote methods may suit situations where onsite work is not feasible or practical.

Your compliance-accepting organization may have its own rules, so check with it first. Any remote activity is documented in section 1.3 of the ROC. Ask each company which activities it plans to perform remotely, and why.

Quality and evidence handling

Every QSA company must keep a documented quality assurance process and manual. It must also classify assessment materials as confidential and retain them for at least three years. Ask how ROCs are reviewed before release, and how your evidence will be stored and protected.

PCI SSC gives you a feedback route too. At the start of each assessment, the QSA company must direct you to the QSA Feedback Form.

How a company earns QSA designation

Understanding the path can help you read a company’s credentials. These are the main stages.

  1. Business requirements. The company shows business legitimacy, documents its independence practices, and carries the required insurance.
  2. Company capability. It shows a dedicated information security practice and audit experience equal to at least one year or three separate audits.
  3. Employee qualification. At least one employee meets the experience and certification requirements and completes PCI SSC training.
  4. Listing and upkeep. PCI SSC adds the company to the QSA List, and the company requalifies annually for each region.

Questions for a first conversation

  • Which regions are you listed for, and do they cover all our in-scope locations?
  • Who will lead the assessment, and what similar environments has that person assessed?
  • Would any of your products or managed services be part of our environment?
  • Which activities do you expect to perform onsite and remotely?
  • How does your quality process review a ROC before release?

Frequently asked questions

What is a QSA?
A Qualified Security Assessor is a person employed by a QSA company and qualified by PCI SSC to perform PCI DSS assessments. The company itself must also be qualified and appear on the QSA List.
Does a QSA need to be onsite for a PCI DSS assessment?
Not always. The QSA Program Guide allows onsite work or remote assessment activities that follow PCI SSC guidance. Remote methods may suit situations where onsite work is not feasible or practical, so confirm with the organization accepting your compliance report.
How does a company gain QSA designation?
The company and at least one employee must satisfy the QSA Qualification Requirements, which cover business legitimacy, independence, insurance, experience, and training. The designation then needs annual requalification by PCI SSC.
What does a red listing on the QSA List mean?
PCI SSC updates a QSA company’s listing to red during its Quality Remediation program, which notifies merchants and service providers. Ask the company what led to the remediation and how it affects your assessment.

Work with RSI Security

RSI Security is a PCI Qualified Security Assessor (QSA) company and an Approved Scanning Vendor (ASV). It performs PCI DSS assessments and quarterly ASV scans. Organizations that need help with scoping or readiness can work with RSI Security through a separate advisory engagement. RSI Security provides either advisory or assessment to a given client, never both.

Schedule a PCI DSS assessment · Talk to an advisor about readiness

Sources

  • QSA Program Guide v4.1 (Sections 2.3 and 2.4, QSA Companies and Customers)
  • QSA Program Guide v4.1 (Section 3, Qualification Process, including 3.1 Requalification and 3.5.1 Regions)
  • QSA Program Guide v4.1 (Sections 4.1, Remote Assessments, 5.4, Feedback Process, and 5.5, Remediation Process)
  • QSA Qualification Requirements v4.2 (Sections 2.1 to 2.3, Business Legitimacy, Independence, and Insurance Coverage)
  • QSA Qualification Requirements v4.2 (Sections 3.1 and 3.2, QSA Company and QSA Employee Requirements)
  • QSA Qualification Requirements v4.2 (Sections 4.3, 4.5, and 5.1, Internal Quality Assurance, Evidence Retention, and QSA List)
  • QSA Qualification Requirements v4.2 (Appendix A, Section A.5, Advertising and Promotion)
  • PCI DSS v4.0.1 (Appendix D, Customized Approach)

Request a consultation