The HITRUST Common Security Framework (CSF) serves as a comprehensive, certifiable framework that integrates various standards and regulations to assist organizations in managing data protection and compliance. Given its extensive scope, encompassing numerous processes, requirements, and standards, it’s not uncommon for entities to encounter challenges during their HITRUST assessments, leading to unsuccessful initial or subsequent attempts. However, there are effective remediation strategies available to address these challenges and achieve certification.
Understanding a Failed HITRUST Assessment
The HITRUST Common Security Framework (CSF) is a comprehensive, certifiable framework that integrates multiple security standards to help organizations manage data protection and compliance. Given its extensive scope, many organizations encounter challenges during HITRUST assessments, sometimes leading to unsuccessful initial attempts. However, failure is not the end of the road—effective remediation strategies can help address deficiencies and achieve certification.
A failed HITRUST assessment typically occurs during the Quality Assurance (QA) phase when unresolved issues or documentation gaps prevent the issuance of a HITRUST CSF Validated Assessment Report. A failed QA does not necessarily indicate poor security practices but may highlight documentation deficiencies, incorrect application of the Control Maturity Scoring Rubric, or inadequate demonstration of control implementation to the external assessor.
Rather than restarting the certification process from scratch, organizations usually enter a Corrective Action Plan (CAP) phase to remediate identified deficiencies and resubmit their assessment.
Steps to Remediate and Achieve HITRUST Certification
To correct a failed QA and maintain compliance, organizations must act quickly. The following key steps will help remediate issues and successfully achieve HITRUST certification.
Step 1: Conduct a Comprehensive Gap Analysis
Begin with a thorough gap analysis to identify security control deficiencies. This involves reviewing all control requirements and evaluating whether policies, procedures, and technologies align with HITRUST CSF standards. Common deficiencies include:
- Missing documentation: Incomplete records on IT assets, security controls, or system inventories.
- Inadequate reporting protocols: Testing or audit results that do not align with HITRUST QA expectations.
- New compliance requirements: Security controls that fall short of updated HITRUST standards.
The HITRUST MyCSF tool can assist in tracking compliance and mapping controls across multiple frameworks, but organizations must proactively assess and adjust their security posture accordingly.
Step 2: Develop and Implement a Remediation Plan
Based on the gap analysis findings, organizations must create a structured remediation plan that includes:
- Technical Requirements: Define the security controls needed to meet HITRUST standards. For example, if multi-factor authentication (MFA) is missing from privileged accounts, the plan should outline integration steps and enforcement policies.
- Assigned Responsibilities: Designate accountable personnel for each task, such as system administrators for MFA deployment and compliance officers for policy enforcement.
- Implementation Timeline: Set deadlines for each phase of remediation, ensuring structured progress and timely completion.
- Verification and Validation: Establish criteria for control validation, such as log reviews, penetration testing, or compliance scans.
Step 3: Engage a Qualified External Assessor
Selecting an experienced external assessor is crucial to a successful reassessment. Organizations should evaluate potential assessors based on their:
- Experience with HITRUST assessments.
- Industry expertise and understanding of sector-specific compliance challenges.
- Track record of guiding organizations through the CAP phase.
As an Authorized HITRUST External Assessor, RSI Security has extensive experience helping organizations navigate HITRUST certification, from gap assessments to full compliance implementation.
Step 4: Enhance Documentation and Evidence Collection
Comprehensive documentation is key to demonstrating compliance. Organizations should ensure that policies, procedures, and implemented controls are well-documented and easily accessible for review. Best practices include:
- High-quality evidence collection: Screenshots should include full application windows, date/time stamps, system identifiers, and relevant configurations.
- Retention of logs and audit trails: Maintain original formats and metadata to validate compliance.
- Consistent documentation updates: Regularly review and revise policies to reflect the latest HITRUST standards.
Since HITRUST requires point-in-time evidence within a defined 90-day assessment period, proactive documentation will prevent delays.
Step 5: Provide Ongoing Training and Awareness Programs
Continuous training ensures that personnel understand their roles in maintaining compliance. Organizations should implement:
- Quarterly security awareness training covering data protection policies and incident response procedures.
- Workshops on HITRUST CSF updates to discuss their implications.
- Certified CSF Practitioner (CCSFP) courses for key compliance stakeholders.
The HITRUST Alliance offers training programs, including refresher courses and certification prep sessions, to help organizations stay updated.
Step 6: Leverage HITRUST Resources and Updates
Staying informed about HITRUST framework updates is critical to maintaining long-term compliance. For example, HITRUST CSF v11.4.0, released in December 2024, introduced consolidated requirement statements and refined scoring methodologies.
Organizations should:
- Regularly review HITRUST updates via the official website and newsletters.
- Utilize the MyCSF tool to track compliance and streamline reassessments.
- Participate in HITRUST webinars and training to gain insights into best practices and evolving compliance challenges.
Turning HITRUST Assessment Failure into a Path to Stronger Security
A failed HITRUST assessment is not a dead end—it’s an opportunity to strengthen security posture. By conducting a gap analysis, implementing a structured remediation plan, engaging experienced assessors, enhancing documentation practices, providing continuous training, and staying updated with HITRUST changes, organizations can address deficiencies and achieve certification.
Partner with RSI Security to navigate your HITRUST journey with expert guidance, proven compliance strategies, and dedicated support. Contact us today to get started!
Contact Us Now!
