Your Web Application Penetration Testing Checklist

If your organization builds or relies on web applications for critical operations, web application penetration testing is essential. This updated guide follows OWASP’s latest standards and aligns with RSI Security’s risk-informed approach to testing. Regular penetration testing helps organizations uncover vulnerabilities, fix security gaps, and ensure their applications are resilient against evolving cyber threats.

OWASP Top 10 Web Application Security Risks for Penetration Testing

The OWASP Top 10 list (2021) is the global benchmark for identifying the most critical web application security risks. Following these risks is essential for effective web application penetration testing. The rankings, based on extensive industry data, include:

• Broken Access Control: Tested in 94% of applications, this is the most common vulnerability, allowing unauthorized users to access or manipulate resources.
• Cryptographic Failures: Previously called “Sensitive Data Exposure,” this category exposes sensitive data if encryption or key management is improperly implemented.
• Injection:  Still ranked #3, with up to 19% incidence. Includes SQL and command injections that allow attackers to manipulate databases or operating systems.
• Insecure Design:  Newly introduced category addressing flaws in overall application architecture that cannot be fixed by patching code.
  
• Security Misconfiguration:  Elevated from #6 in 2017; weaknesses caused by improper configurations or missing security settings affect about 4.5% of applications.
  
• Vulnerable and Outdated Components:  Emphasizes risks from outdated or unpatched libraries and dependencies.
  
• Identification and Authentication Failures:  Formerly “Broken Authentication,” focuses on weaknesses in verifying user identities and session security.
• Software and Data Integrity Failures:  Includes insecure software updates, deserialization flaws, and pipeline integrity issues that compromise applications.
• Security Logging and Monitoring Failures:  Makes it difficult to detect and respond to breaches, allowing attackers to persist undetected.
• Server-Side Request Forgery (SSRF):  Less common (~2.7%) but can allow attackers to manipulate servers into making unauthorized requests.

Key Update: OWASP is expected to revise the Top 10 in 2025. Organizations should monitor Emerging threats such as API abuse, cloud misconfigurations, and supply chain vulnerabilities to keep their programs up to date.

OWASP Web Security Testing Guide (WSTG) for Web Application Penetration Testing

The OWASP Web Security Testing Guide (WSTG, version 4.x) is a comprehensive reference for conducting web application penetration testing. It provides structured guidance to test every part of an application’s security posture and organize assessments into key domains:

• Information Gathering: Identify application endpoints and potential entry points for attackers.
• Configuration and Deployment Testing: Detect insecure settings, unpatched servers, and other deployment risks.
• Identity and Authentication Testing: Evaluate login mechanisms, session handling, and multi-factor authentication.
• Authorization and Access Control Testing: Ensure access permissions are correctly enforced across user roles.
• Session Management Testing: Examine token handling and logout processes to prevent session hijacking.
• Input Validation Testing: Check for injection vulnerabilities, including SQL, OS, and XSS attacks.
• Error Handling: Verify that error messages do not expose sensitive information.
• Cryptography Testing: Assess encryption methods, key management, and secure data handling practices.
• Business Logic Testing:  Review custom workflows to detect exploitable design flaws.
• Client-Side and API Testing: Identify weaknesses in JavaScript, browser storage, and exposed APIs.

Modern enhancements now include API and microservices security assessments, static and dynamic analysis tools, and integration with CI/CD pipelines. These steps strengthen web application penetration testing by catching vulnerabilities early in the development cycle.

Need a Penetration Test? Learn more.

Aligning Web Application Penetration Testing with NIST SP 800-30 Rev. 1

While OWASP focuses on technical security testing, NIST SP 800-30 Rev. 1 provides a complementary risk assessment framework. This guide helps organizations manage broader cybersecurity risks beyond individual applications and strengthens enterprise-wide web application penetration testing efforts.

Key processes include:

• Identifying and Analyzing Threats: Evaluate vulnerabilities across entire IT systems.
• Prioritizing Remediation Efforts:  Focus on issues based on the likelihood and potential impact of cyber incidents.
• Integrating Penetration Testing Results: Use findings from web application penetration testing to inform overall risk management strategies.
  

Healthcare and other regulated industries can leverage NIST SP 800-30 to ensure penetration testing aligns with compliance requirements such as HIPAA’s Security Rule.

Additional Considerations for Web Application Penetration Testing

Effective penetration testing requires selecting the right approach based on your organization’s environment and risk profile. Common testing methods include:

• External Testing: Simulates attacks from outside the network perimeter to identify entry points and exposure risks.
• Internal Testing: Assesses lateral movement, privilege escalation, and insider threat scenarios once initial access is gained.
• Hybrid Testing:  Combines external and internal testing to cover the entire attack surface.
  

Modern applications often need specialized testing for cloud-native components, containerized environments, and APIs. Incorporating runtime monitoring and post-exploit validation helps organizations understand not only whether an attack succeeds but also how effectively it is detected and contained.

Building Your Tailored Web Application Penetration Testing Checklist

A strong web application penetration testing checklist starts with OWASP’s Top 10 and WSTG resources but should be customized to match your organization’s architecture and compliance requirements. When building your checklist, consider:

• Application Complexity: Monolithic versus microservices or API-driven frameworks.
• Applicable Regulations: HIPAA, PCI DSS, CMMC, GDPR, and other relevant standards.
• Internal Security Capabilities: Determine if internal resources are sufficient or if external advisory support is needed.

Partnering with a trusted cybersecurity and compliance advisory like RSI Security ensures your testing is comprehensive, aligned with best practices, and tailored to your risk environment. This collaboration helps organizations remediate vulnerabilities efficiently and strengthen their long-term security posture.

Leverage Web Application Penetration Testing for Stronger Security

The OWASP Top 10 and Web Security Testing Guide (WSTG) remain the gold standard for web application penetration testing. Organizations that regularly update testing protocols, include modern attack vectors, and align assessments with broader frameworks like NIST SP 800-30 are better prepared to defend against evolving cyber threats.

RSI Security experienced cybersecurity team uses OWASP methodologies and the latest threat intelligence to deliver actionable results and prioritize risk mitigation strategies.

Protect your organization today: schedule a web application penetration test with RSI Security to safeguard against today’s most sophisticated attacks.

As a cybersecurity expert offering pen testing services and security program advisory, RSI Security can help guide your efforts.